The Long Game: How Subscription Metrics Change CRO Priorities

TLDR

Conversion rates can lie.

In subscription brands, optimising for the wrong metrics can actually hurt your business. 

We explain why traditional CRO success metrics like conversion rates and immediate revenue become need to balance against longer-term indicators like customer retention and lifetime value, and how brands that optimise purely for CRO metrics often discover their "successful" tests could actually harm long-term performance.

—

Full article

Conversion rates can lie. In subscription brands, optimising for the wrong metrics could actually hurt your business.

CRO performance metrics celebrate when conversion rates go up. More visitors buying means more revenue, right?

Well, in subscription businesses, it's not always that simple.

If your conversion rate improvements attract subscribers who cancel quickly, you might actually be hurting your business performance.

This is one of the biggest mindset shifts needed for subscription optimisation. Traditional metrics like conversion rates and AOV become less important than longer-term indicators like customer retention and lifetime value.

Why Conversion Rates Could Mislead

Imagine you test a new pricing page that doubles your conversion rate. Your CRO metrics would call this a massive win. But what if those extra conversions came from customers who weren't willing to pay full price and cancelled as soon as their discount expired?

Three months later, you might discover that while you got more signups, your overall revenue actually decreased because the quality of customers declined. Your "successful" test actually made your business performance worse.

This is why subscription brands need to think differently about success metrics. A lower conversion rate that attracts better long-term customers might be far more valuable than a higher conversion rate that attracts customers who don't stick around.

Metrics That Actually Matter

In subscription brands, the metrics that best predict success often have nothing to do with initial conversions. Things like onboarding completion rates, time to first value, early engagement patterns, and feature adoption rates are much better predictors of business health.

For example, if 80% of your trial users complete your onboarding process and 70% of those convert to paid subscriptions, improving onboarding completion might be more valuable than improving initial trial signups.

The best subscription businesses track cohort performance over time.

They look at how groups of customers perform months after signing up, not just how many people converted this week. This gives them much better insights into which optimisation efforts actually drive business value.

Shifting from Conversion Focus to Lifetime Value

Optimising for customer lifetime value requires a balanced approach than just looking at acquisition. But it starts to pose questions like:

• Instead of removing all friction from the signup process, why not add qualifying questions that filter out unlikely long-term customers?

• Instead of making trial signups as easy as possible, why not add initial engagement or setup that indicates genuine interest?

• Instead of optimising purely for speed, why not slow down the process to ensure customers understand what they're signing up for?

This doesn't mean making things deliberately difficult.

It means optimising for customer success rather than just customer conversion. The goal is attracting customers who will succeed with your product, not just customers who will sign up for it.

How Traditional Metrics Can Hurt Subscription Businesses

CRO metrics can't be the sole performance metric for subscription brands, as they could misdirect optimisation efforts. From a subscriptions perspective, high immediate conversion rates might indicate you're attracting the wrong customers. Short onboarding processes might improve initial satisfaction but hurt long-term engagement.

Businesses that optimise purely for traditional metrics often discover that their most "successful" tests could actually harm long-term business performance. They might convert more visitors but see higher churn rates, lower engagement, and worse overall unit economics.

The solution is implementing measurement systems that connect initial conversion events with long-term customer behaviour. You need to understand how different signup experiences affect retention rates and lifetime value, not just how they affect conversion rates.

Building Better Measurement Systems

Effective subscription optimisation requires measurement systems that track customer behaviour over extended periods and connect specific optimisation changes with long-term outcomes.

This means setting up tracking that follows customers from initial website visit through months of subscription usage. You need to understand which traffic sources produce the best long-term customers, which onboarding sequences drive the highest retention, and which pricing strategies optimise for lifetime value.

The businesses building the most sustainable subscription growth have learned to be patient with their optimisation efforts. They test changes and wait months to evaluate their true impact. They optimise for metrics that predict long-term success rather than immediate gratification.

This approach requires different skills and patience compared to CRO, but it's essential for building successful subscription businesses.

Ready to audit your subscriptions? 

Get your FILDI Subscription Performance Audit now, identify exactly what's costing you money and get the roadmap to fix it.

—

What does a Subscriptions Audit entail? We conduct deep analysis across your subscription data to present a comprehensive performance picture. Our proven methodology examines customer lifetime value, acquisition costs, growth efficiency, and retention patterns.

More importantly, you'll receive specific and actionable recommendations based on our findings. We don't just tell you what's broken, but we’ll also prioritise what to fix now

Our audit delivers immediate value: clear identification of your biggest revenue leaks, specific opportunities for growth and a strategic plan you can implement.

—